Become an Affiliate  Suggest A Book  Gift Certificates  Jenn's Blog: A Bookseller's Tale  Frequent Buyer Card  About us  Help  
Indigocafe.com :: Columns & Reviews :: Book Review :: Erasure by Percival L. Everett
Book Review
by Percival L. Everett

Reviewer: Geoff Wisner, Staff Reviewer
Posted: December 10, 2007
I found out about Erasure from a reading list that accompanied the article Writers Like Me by Martha Southgate, about the obstacles that face black writers in America. The list included David Bradley and Reginald McKnight, two of my favorite authors, so I figured it was worth digging deeper.

Erasure is so good that I was embarrassed not to know about it already. It was doubly embarrassing to find that the author has published thirteen previous books that I also knew nothing about. My ignorance seemed to underline Southgate’s point about the difficulty black writers face in getting attention for their work. The subject of the novel makes the same point in another way.

Thelonious Monk Ellison, the protagonist of Erasure, is the author of four novels and one collection of stories: serious literary work that has gone largely ignored by the public, especially when it deals with subjects (like the ancient Persians) that don’t fit publishers’ and the public’s idea of what black writers should write about.

Ellison has other problems. His sister, a doctor who works in an inner-city clinic, is being threatened by anti-abortion fanatics. His mother is showing signs of Alzheimer’s. And his brother, who has discovered he’s gay after marrying and raising a family, is not much help in any of this.

Then a black woman named Juanita Mae Jenkins publishes a novel called We’s Lives in Da Ghetto, a saga of inner-city life told in dialogue that would not be out of place in a minstrel show. The book is a major hit, and the author appears on the Book Club segment of a TV show whose popular talk show host will remind you of someone.

Angry and offended, Ellison sets out to write a satire of this kind of faux-ghetto trash so extreme that no one could miss the point that these books degrade and caricature the lives of black people. Erasure includes the full text: 67 pages of low-down behavior related in gutter language. I admit I could not make myself read it all. But I got the idea.

Anyone who has seen Spike Lee’s Bamboozled (released not long before this book appeared) can guess what happens next: Ellison’s novel, published under an obvious pseudonym, is hailed as a literary masterpiece.

In Erasure, Ellison and the author wrestle with some difficult questions. Why is so much “serious” literature, Ellison’s included, so small and cautious and academic? Why does Ellison find it so hard to write about his own most urgent concerns? And why are both whites and blacks so quick to embrace the worst aspects of black life as “real” and “authentic” and “powerful”?

Bitter, touching, uncomfortable, and very funny, Erasure is one of the most surprising and compelling novels I’ve read in a long time.

About the Reviewer
Geoff Wisner is a freelance writer and staff member of Indigocafe.com. He is the author of
A Basket of Leaves: 99 Books That Capture the Spirit of Africa. Visit his website at www.geoffwisner.com.

posted by: Geoff | more from this member Print Article 
1 Comments[ Add Your Comment ]

Posted: Dec 14, 2007 - 06:57 PM

I stumbled on your post during a moment of idle surfing. You put it up on my birthday and it is a wonderful birthday present to see that the reading list I compiled to accompany my article motivated you to pick up Percival Everett's criminally underappreciated "Erasure". It's really a thrill to see it here. I'm glad you enjoyed it and shared it with the world. That's the kind of thing I hoped would happen when I wrote that piece for the NYTBR. Thanks!


“Be the change you want to see in the world.”
—Mahatma Gandhi